Monday, April 2, 2018

The "Repression Machine:" Telling Albania's Story


In March, I spent a week in Tirana, Albania, at the invitation of the United States Embassy in Tirana, facilitating conversations and workshops about possibilities for a rejuvenated National History Museum.  More on that experience later, but first to discuss a bit about Albania's history and the stories that museums and archives are sharing with visitors and my learning at two historic sites and one archive.

If you're like me, you don't know much about Albania's complex and fascinating history, but the part this post focuses on is the Enver Hoxha communist regime, established after the defeat of the Nazis in 1945.  This regime was initially allied with the Soviet Union, but broke away and became unaligned, and isolated from almost everywhere. The only way I can describe it is as a paranoid state that distrusted everyone, but most of all its own citizens.  In the years since the early 1990s, Albania, like many other states, has been coming to terms with its Communist legacy.  It's not an easy task, particularly as this did not involve an invader or outside oppressor, say as in the Czech Republic, but an entirely home-grown system of repression.


I learned about this history by visiting three places doing exceptional work:  the House of Leaves, Spaç Prison, and the State Security Archives.  Each one provided food for thought for anyone thinking about ways to interpret difficult issues, in this case, the "machine of repression," as Genta Sula, head of the archives, described it.


The House of Leaves is right in the center of Tirana and only opened as a museum less than a year ago. But the House itself has been long-known to Albanians.  It's the former headquarters of the state surveillance service, sequestered behind a high wall covered with leaves.  It's now a museum devoted to helping visitors understand surveillance: who did, how they did it, why they did it, and more.  From the House of Leaves I remember how much the graphic black and white design served the story.  There were loads and loads of charts--ordinarily something I might not be attracted to--but room-sized, they actually drew you in.  The mechanics of the surveillance were fascinating--and also unsettling.  You could see how some people just saw the surveillance as a technical problem to be solved, not a human rights question. And then that began to raise some unsettling questions about the state of surveillance today in the larger world.


But most importantly for me, was the sense that, throughout the entire museum, that the exhibits were based on real, individual stories.  This was brought home to me as I entered one room that listed all the people imprisoned or killed by the regime.  An Albanian colleague with me went quiet, looked up, and said, "here's my grandfather."  Those stories, one by one, are a large part of what gave the museum its exceptional power to me. The other power came from what was unsaid:  that we think about this state-sponsored surveillance, but about how we're just starting to think about the kind of corporate surveillance that we willingly surrender to.

Some of the raw material for the content of this exhibit comes from the state security archives, newly opened after more than twenty-five years.  You can come to the archives and see your own file--some of them thousands and thousands of pages.  The total archives is more than 22 million pages.  You begin to understand the web of connections:  the government spied on you, and then convince you to spy on others--and so much information was fundamentally useless--but still used to intimidate and imprison others.  Genta Sula, the director of the Authority for the Information on Former Communist Police Secret Files (that's the archives official name) views the archives also as an activist tool.  The archives are working with artist Alketa Xhafa Mripa, who is producing "Even the Walls have Ears,"  testimonies from the archives to be projected on public buildings this spring.  If there's one thing I've learned in my year at Sites of Conscience,  it's that archives can be really powerful.  These archives are a great example of both documentation and activism.


The last site of note was not quite a museum yet--and it took me far out of Tirana.  Three staff members of Cultural Heritage without Borders, a Sites of Conscience member, took me out to visit Spaç Prison. Far up in the mountains, the prison and labor camp was established by the regime and housed a number of Albanian intellectuals and opponents of the Hoxha regime.  It's been designated as a heritage site, but sadly neglected and Cultural Heritage without Borders has taken on the effort to turn it into a site of memory and a museum.  For me, several important elements stood out here:  first, the power of place.  Although most of the way to the prison is now a paved road, it used to be a very long drive to get to this remote place.  And once here, you understand that the regime's goal of isolating you and attempting to control every aspect of your life.  "Inspirational" quotes from Hoxha are still on the walls juxtaposed with one prisoner's list of movie stars on a cell wall.


But this site also reveals the challenge of dealing with the past.  The site is owned by the government and the mine itself has been leased to a Turkish company, who is rapidly changing everything around the "red line" of the historic site, as you can see in the above photo.  The buildings at the top of the photo are all new. This region, like all of Albania, is interested in economic development--hence the mine lease.  Which will win out?  Cultural  Heritage without Borders has developed a thoughtful plan for the ongoing development of the site as a site of memory--and a place where young people can not only learn about the past and but also shape a more just future.

I found one commonality in all these experiences: virtually everyone I met, of course, had their own story of these times and their family or personal experiences.  It's the integration of these personal voices that provides the strength of these places and the involvement of those affected by the regime is critical.  Everyone noted that Albanian society has a long way to go in the complex process of reconciliation, but each of these experiences showed the power that museums, historic sites, and archives can have in moving towards that reconciliation if they are unafraid.


46 comments:

karen dish said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Nicole said...

Very nice post here thanks for it I always like and search such topics and everything connected to them. Keep update more information..

Logistics Software
Fleet Management Software
ERP Software Companies

Eaalim Institute said...

Great blog, Thanks.



He is a man from Jannah , Angels of Allah, KHALID BIN WALID TAKES POISON, The Supplication of Musa, Who is ad-Dayuth?, Ask Allah for everything, True Story of Prophet Yunus, learn quran online, learn quran online uk, quran teacher online,
quran teacher needed, need quran teacher online

Edmund said...

Nice post. Thanks for sharing this useful information.

Vehicle tracking system
Fleet management software

Bangalore Web Guru said...

I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. thanks
Website Design Company Bangalore | Website Development Bangalore | Web Development Bangalore

Jessica Max said...

Thanks for sharing your knowledge .Keep sharing it.

School bus app
School bus tracker

Sappa Lama Gomso said...

Everest Base Camp Trek is one of those journeys that create your vacation dreams return true. Hiking on the legendary foothills just under the mighty Mount Everest 8848m with exciting views of the master peaks will solely be found within the Everest Region. This celebrated trek is thought worldwide for its trailblazing routes & the landscapes speak to your senses. On this trip you furthermore Mera peak out at the celebrated Kala Patthar (5,600m/18,373ft) read purpose for a few grand direct views of the very best mountain in the world. Everest Base CampTrek additionally includes different celebrated eight thousand peaks like Mt mountain peak (8,516m /27,940ft), Makalu (8,485m /27,838 ft) Cho-Oyu (8,201m /26,906ft). The culture of this specific space is of nice notebook stuff & interacting with the native of us puts a lot of zest into your venturesome journey as you walk through the Khumbu region of the Asian country. This legendary path could be a psychological thriller for top & wild hikers World Health Organization want the tread the methods wherever legends walked before on their thanks to conquering mountain peak, some did some didn’t however the Everest Base Camp Trek path keeps those legends alive for many trekkers World Health Organization head to the present region. The trip begins with a stirring mountain flight to Lukla, one among the world’s highest mountains; & as shortly as you set down at that altitude, the remainder is history. Your hike takes you to the favored village city of Namche, referred to as the ‘gateway to the Khumbu’’ & from there on you rehearse quiet monasteries with the acknowledge Sherpa of us World Health Organization inhabit this region & their culture is price noting. On the way, we have a tendency to visit the Sagarmatha parkland, home to some rare fauna & flora, this additionally wherever we have a tendency to adapt for a few time. We head deep into the Khumbu hiking into the forest of shrub, birch trees & pine, with colorful villages wherever we have a tendency to square measure sincerely welcome by the Sherpa community. we have a tendency to square measure pleasantly stunned to return across a hospital-based mostly in Khunde and health post at Pheriche that shows this region not solely cares for the locals however also are able to look out of trekkers World Health Organization have altitude issues. Doctors square measure invariably at the post for aid treatment. The Everest Base Camp Trek is arduous however varied teahouses square measure found on the paths providing smart grubbed to shelter from the generally harsh climate. Our trek culminates at base camp so we have a tendency to create a path for Namche as we have a tendency to hike back to Lukla to rendezvous for our flight to Katmandu. we have a tendency to add an additional contingency day for inclement weather which will delay flights. It’s recommended to be pretty acceptable to undertake this journey; you only want some smart hiking exercise before doing this trip. And Nepal Base Camp Treks can do the remainder to allow you AN action-packed odyssey of a period.

Nadeem Malik said...

hello sir,
thanks for giving that type of information.
digital marketing company in delhi

Akash Thakur said...

Doors manufacturer in Hubli

Sappa Lama Gomso said...

Annapurna Base Camp Trek is an amazing walk through diverse landscapes and culture complete with rich mountain views. This route lies in the Annapurna region of Nepal which is the very much beautiful place in Nepal. The trek is incorporated diverse terrain, culture, and wildlife. It is a popular choice among diverse outdoors enthusiasts, from a solo female traveler to hikers traveling in groups to Nepal. Their beauty is indescribable and they draw your attention and walking further leads to the Lush forest to waterfalls. We get the chance to see wonderful views of the mountain, landscapes, small villages, the beautiful scenery, and the small waterfalls of this route. The fabulous mountain scenery and the rich cultural diversity traverses across a wide spectrum of lush rural farmlands and pretty villages. We will walk through terraced rice paddies, lush rhododendron forest and high altitude landscapes with the Annapurna region in view most of the time. Many villages perched on ridges tops surrounded by ancient terraced fields. We cross the mountain passes, fascinating mid-hills, colorful villages and slowly gaining an altitude to the base camp of the world’s greatest peaks. The steep sides are covered in the Lush forest and it is the most dramatic treks in this region.
Annapurna Base Camp Trek is one of the most popular walks on the earth. The starting point of this trekking route is Pokhara city which is also known as the city of the Lake. While trekking in this route, we will pass through the many suspension bridges and a small natural hot spring of this route. At the time of trekking, we get chance to know about the culture, traditions, and lifestyle of the Gurung, Magar, and Thakali people who are the local inhabitants of this route. We will have great chance to see the wonderful vies of the Mountain which includes Dhaulagiri, Machapuchhre, Annapurna south, and many other mountains of this region. During the time of trekking, we get the chance to explore the Annapurna Conservation Area which is home to many rare birds, animals, flora, and fauna. The best season is February to April and October to December for trekking in this route. The Annapurna base camp trek is one of the beautiful treks in the Annapurna region. The good trail is often neatly stepped, as far as the prosperous villages of Chhomrong. After a good scenic walk reaching the Base Camp with ample time to marvel and enjoy the mountain views.

Nadeem Malik said...

outdoor led flood lights in delhi

sachin.ogeninfo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sachin.ogeninfo said...

English Song lyrics

Digital marketing in Delhi said...

We are happy now to see this post because of the you put good images, good choice of the words. You choose best topic and good information provide. Thanks a sharing nice article.

Digital marketing company in delhi

Shiva Excursion said...

Trekking in Nepal is one in all the favored commercial enterprise activities in Nepal trekking is one in all the simplest means of experiencing the natural beauty and wealthy cultural
heritage of Nepal. Nepal treks offers snow capped views of Nepal Himalaya, stunning landscape, totally different ethnic teams & their traditions, welcome, lush valleys through forests of bush, bamboo, oak, and hemlock, visiting one or 2 villages to next trekking destination. Nepal isn't merely walking hiking sooner or later when another, it's rather a gradual means of experiencing of Nepal's diversity in terms of earth science, people, faith and a large vary of culture. Shiva Excursion is Local Trekking Agency in Nepal may be each day hike to nduce to the highest on a mountain or a ridge for the spectacular views of mountain chain peaks or it may be a hiking for a month passing through villages within the shadow of lofty snow peaks, valleys, notch experiencing wealthy culture, custom and also the impressive views of the Himalaya in Asian nation. the target of Trekking in Nepal isn't simply the actual destination, however the journey itself. You travel at a modest pace, observant nature, rural communities, and spectacular mountain panoramas whereas you're trekking in Himalaya . Shiva Excursion old trekking guide can lead for path finding an introduction to the native individuals, culture, faith and mode. Under Nepal Government License holder Trekking Company in Nepal which is lead by Over 20 Years Trekking and Tour Operation Highly Recommend Everest Base Camp Trek and Annapurna Base Camp Trek. Because these Trip are most Popular and Challenging and top Destination in Nepal. Most of the Adventure, Moderate, and Easy hiking and Hard Passes Organized in Nepal. not that much enough some of Top Peak Climbing as Island Peak Climbing, Mera Peak Climbing, Lobuche Peak and Many others real adventure path of Nepal. In Nepal More then 3000 threkking Agencies and all are competion for the business sector. Some one selling cheapest and some one selling top and quality service. those Agencies as over 30% are fake travel dealing.

AKASH DAYAL GROUPS said...

THANKS FOR INFORMATION

you can search low-cost website with high-quality website functions.
Today Join Us
Call: +91 - 8076909847

website designing company delhi

levantro
best interior designers in delhi


livewebindia
website designing company

seo services delhi

Best It Service Provider:

1. Website Designing And Development.
2. SEO Services.
3. Software Development.
4. Mobile App Development.

Unknown said...

Merry Christmas,
You are so interesting! I don't believe I've truly read through anything like that before. So wonderful to discover another person with a few unique thoughts on this issue. Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This website is something that is required on the internet, someone with a bit of originality! If you want to read merry christmas quotes for coworkers you have to see the link
Thank you,

tamir said...

Hi,
The very next time I read a blog, I hope that it does not disappoint me as much as this particular one.New Year Wishes Messages I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I truly thought you would probably have something useful to say. All I hear is a bunch of crying about something that you could possibly fix if you were not too busy searching for attention.
Thanks

Y and H Cargo India said...

Nice blog! Thanks for sharing with us. It was really helpful for me. Visit for
Logistics Company in India
Freight Forwarders in India

liooo said...

tutuapp
itube
tutuapp download
tutuapp Android
tutuapp-ios/

sachin.ogeninfo said...

refrigerator repair in gurgaon
lg fridge repair in gurgaon
washing machine repair in gurgaon

sachin.ogeninfo said...

Haier Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Panasonic Fridge Repair In Faridabad

sachin.ogeninfo said...

plastic pouch manufacturers in delhi
wall putty bag manufacturers
gusseted bags manufacturers

sachin.ogeninfo said...

website designing company in Gurgaon
ppc company in Gurgaon
seo company in Gurgaon

مروة محمد said...

شركة تنظيف بالقطيف

Lyrics said...

Welcome to AZLyrics! It's a place where all searches end! We have a large, legal, every day growing universe of lyrics where stars of all genres and ages shine.

رجب البرنس said...


شركة تنظيف خزانات بحائل
شركة تنظيف فلل بحائل
شركة تسليك مجارى بحائل


Buna Treks & Expedition Pvt. Ltd. said...

Why Trekking in Nepal Nepal?, a land of high hills, mountains, raging rivers and verdant deep jungles of Terai & its rich lifestyle makes one of the most sought locations inside the map of the world. a destination for all season as it's miles one of the most numerous and varied international locations on this planet a unique us of a nestled inside the excellent snow capped variety is some other advent of the mom earth and it embraces worlds' 8 highest peaks from mt.everest, mt.kanchenjonga, mt.lhotse, Makalu, Cho Oyu, Dhaulagiri, Manaslu to Annapurna massive. nepal is likewise the beginning location of Buddha (light of Asia). The Buna Treks is Local Base Under Nepal Government Trekking Agency in Nepal. blessed with wealthy nature, the brilliant Himalayan in Nepal range stretches from the far north-west to the way east where the worlds highest 8th eight-thousanders are in Nepal. nepal gives a enthralling adventure with enough time to wonder the encompassing beautiful landscapes and immerse with its warm human beings, imparting you full of range and enchantment from the low lands of Gangetic plains and its verdant dense jungle where the endangered species of Royal Bengal tigers and the one-horned rhinoceros roam, to the mythical yak and yeti trail to Everest.as the adventure and leisure tourism was hooked up in view that late 1960 and 70’s quality travel & trekking enterprise have mushroomed by using a tourism professionals Nepalese, and were leading countless of adventure trips in the course of Himalaya consisting of rafting, mountain climbing also organize adventure trekking, and entertainment trips which includes tailor-made itineraries for own family, college companies and company executives. Many of Trekking Company in Nepal are not perfect trip dealing, they have not enough Experienced. Trekking in Nepal, Nepal is domestic to community of trails also known as the amazing Himalaya trails, an extensive trail gadget that covers Nepal from humble and Darchula within the west to Kanchenjunga in the east. the range of Trekking in Nepal cannot be located in any other location of the world. in fact, the lowest factor in Nepal is fifty-nine m above sea-level inside the terai location even as the very best point is Everest, eight,848 m above sea-level, the two factors are, in a direct line, most effective two hundred kilometers aside. the majority of visitors to Nepal are available through the Tribhuvan international airport in Kathmandu. it's far in Kathmandu that trekkers want to accumulate their permits and other documentation, both from a trekking agent or from the best places of work. those files will be checked along the hiking route. for people with little time to spend in Nepal, there are half of-day hikes from Kathmandu to witness breathtaking Himalayan Trekking in Nepal perspectives in any other case trek for weeks over stunning tough mountain passes. as much as the mid-1960s just a few trekkers had generally visited Nepal and lower back then as part of corporations of excursion fans. the various huge expeditions of the day recommended trekkers to join up in an try to help balance the investment.

مروة محمد said...

شركة تسليك مجارى بالخبر

Splendid Interiors said...

Awesome article! It is in detail and well formatted that i enjoyed reading. which inturn helped me to get new information from your blog.
Find the Interior Designers in Vizag

Dhansingh Gurung Gurung said...

The Manaslu trekking is one of the best trekking destination in the western part of Nepal Kathmandu. The Manaslu Tsum valley trek and Manaslu area is restricted for the foreigner if you want to travel in your once life you should buy special permit for the Manaslu trek. It is pretty expensive but after enter this area then you will feel wow this is the one of the real life adventure and real local culture you could get a mix tradition. Here if you want a travel normally you should more than two people with a guide as if you hire porter that is your choice. The Manaslu trek is start from Soti-khola which is reach after 7/8 hours drive from Kathmandu first day following Trisuli river then the end Budigandaki river viewing agriculture platform and tradition local houses and the lot of green hilly region jungle. This trek normally take 14 days if include Tsum valley will be more days. The Manaslu area is locally base culture and old traditional ethnic group people living area in the Nepal. All the trekking trial is follow Budi –Gundaki river till top of the Manalsu Larke which is (5106m) above the sea level most challenging all of you those travel while you are doing there.

After the top is going downhill which is long way down inter the Annapurna Region. the manalsu circuit trek is finish Dharapani where is last check point for the special permit some one walk till Tall then from there can drive to Besi Shar and to Kathmandu any kind of drive luxury or any kind of bus. This is trekking route you will see specifically view of top of the high mount Manalsu lot of the other specutular mountain view so the people uphold the trekking route to doing but the most of people feel on them anxious due to high elevation. When you doing this manalsu Larke pass trek you should keep positively of course everyone can success trip Everest Trekking Routes help 100% trip success so kindly join us team work with ETR

Everest Trekking Routes Pvt. Ltd.
Khusibu, Nayabazaar, Kathmandu, Nepal
Tel: + 977-1-4387202
Mobile : +977-9843451231, 9843467921
Email :info@manaslutsumvalleytrekking.com
Email: info@everesttrekkingroutes.com
ULL:- www.manaslutsumvalleytrekking.com
URL:- www.everesttrekkingroutes.com

Ogen Infosystem said...

This was really informative and valuable information. Visit for the creative Website Designing and Development Services by Ogen Info system.
E-commerce Website Designing Company in Delhi

Y and H Cargo India said...

Visit for the best Logistics and Freight Forwarders Companies in Delhi at Y & H Cargo India.
Shipping Company in Delhi

Spin Gurus said...

Spin Gurus is provided you the best service of Music Production.
Music Production Courses

Mutual Fundwala said...

Nice Blog. If you Need best Mutual Fund in India MutualFundWala is best for you.
Mutual Fund Distributor

Mobile App Development in Noida said...

Thanks for the article may be useful for everything

easy persuasive speech topics said...

Thank you for this post.This is very interesting information for me.

Mobile App Development company in Mumbai said...

Thanks for sharing valuable Information, I really very impressive on your blog. I hope you continue on blogging job.

Neelam said...

Hi All,
If any one is looking out for a SEO service provider in Delhi,NCR then I would like to share the name of I such company which ranked among the Top SEO services provider company in Delhi (www.nexcuit.com) they are providing the best SEO service in Delhi, here you can get the best professional services within your budget and as per your given timeline this company is among one of the top most companies which provide SEO services in India as of now there Office is situated in East Delhi which is close to Nirman Vihar metro station.For more details please dial +919910326510 and get more insights concerning their charges, 100% satisfaction guaranteed.

seo services in India

seo company in delhi

nexcuit said...

I am grateful to the owner of this site which really shares this wonderful work of this site. That is actually great and useful information. I would also like to share some useful information regarding SEO services in Delhi(www.nexcuit.com)This is the best SEO company in Laxmi Nagar, East Delhi. So if anyone is looking out for the Best SEO company in Delhi then reach out to them on the given number+919910326510 and get more details related to the packages they offer and their prices. One thing I can bet on is that you will get 100% satisfaction from there services.

seo services in delhi
best seo company in delhi
seo company in delhi
seo company in laxmi nagar

amir said...

I am grateful to the owner of this site which really shares this wonderful work of this site. That is actually great and useful information. I would also like to share some useful information.If you are Looking for the satta result Delhi Darbar in delhi,ncr or satta result Gali, satta result Deshawar. Then open the below link for more details.

satta result Taj
satta result Delhi Darbar
satta result Gali
satta result Deshawar
Disawar Satta Result
satta result Ghaziabad
satta result Faridabad

satta king shri ganesh
satta result chart
satta king chart
satta king result
satta bazar result

bestieltscoachingindwarka said...

I feel happy about and learning more about this topic. keep sharing your information regularly for my future reference. This content creates new hope and inspiration within me. Thanks for sharing an article like this. the information which you have provided is better than another blog.
IELTS Coaching in Dwarka
Best IELTS Coaching in Dwarka

pay someone to do my homework said...

Many thanks for this post, this is what I need, I will definitely try.

james said...

When you want search engine optimization in bangalore , you need to choose best seo company who can help to achieve results

Dinesh said...

Thanks for giving that type of information. Really enjoyed this blog post. I would also like to share some useful information.If you are Looking for the satta result Delhi Darbar in delhi,ncr or satta result Gali, satta result Deshawar. Then open the mention link for more details.

satta king Faridabad satta king Gali satta king Desawar

nexcuit said...

I am grateful to the owner of this site which really shares this wonderful work of this site. That is actually great and useful information. I would also like to share some useful information regarding digital marketing company in delhii(www.nexcuit.com)This is the digital marketing company in delhi located in Laxmi Nagar, East Delhi. So if anyone is looking out for the Best SEO company in Delhi then reach out to them on the given number+919910326510 and get more details.related to the packages they offer and their prices. One thing I can bet on is that you will get 100% satisfaction from there services.
digital marketing company in delhii
Best Digital marketing agency serving in Delhi
best digital marketing company in Delhi NCR
SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION (SEO)